Discuss the “technocrats” as described in chapter 4:
There is need to secure a country’s border from insurgents and other criminals. Many countries experience insecurity because of how porous its borders are. It is important for governments of such countries to come up with security policies that tighten security in such regions in order to stop illegal immigrants. America has been in the forefront in championing for cross-border security. Canada has come up with a new approach to uphold border security (Alper & Loucky,2007). This paper discusses technocrats basing on whether Canada was appropriate starting point for technocrats’ new approach on border security.
A technocrat is an expert who has important knowledge that can be used to govern or to manage a specific region or government. In United States and Canada, there was the introduction of new approach to border security which was initiated by technocrats who wanted security to be upheld. However, targeting Canada as appropriate starting point of this policy was a point of discussion all over America. This technocratic approach ensures that prevention and intelligence is enforced properly at the border (Herzog, 2001).
Question For This Technocrat Essay is:
In 2-3 pages, and using APA style formatting, discuss the “technocrats” as described in chapter 4. Was Canada the appropriate starting point for their new approach on border security architecture?
Canada was used as an experimental approach for this new border security. This is majorly because of size, significance, wealth and use of common language. First, its size is vast hence need some surveillance to ensure that no illegal insurgents are left to get into either United States or Canada. Secondly, its wealth is significant hence able to fund the personnel and technology that is used in surveillance and data collection. Information based on each and every person who crosses the border should be taken up in order to raise cross-border security. Other countries may not be in a position to fund these high technological innovations of border security. Technocrats saw it wise to choose Canada for this case. In addition, traditions of both Americans and Canadians are based on high level of law enforcement which in many cases is highly computerized. Both of them are also computer literate hence employing this new approach will be an advantage because of partnership and knowledge in upholding cross-border security between the two countries (Alper&Loucky, 2007).
On basis of common language, this new approach suits Canada as a starting point. Canada and America share common language. This would reduce any form of friction that might exist as a result of language barriers. There is an essence of smooth movement and flow of people across the border hence this was important for both economies. According to Canadian Action Plan, “border weight time measurement system” is essential as part of technocratic approach in order to improve cross-border security between the two countries. Transportation agencies are provided with information for real-time wait-time in order to facilitate ease in management of their resources. Drivers are also given chance to make informed decisions about appropriate time to cross border. This would improve surveillance hence upholding security (Herzog, 2001).
In conclusion, Technocrats are important experts who work hard to implement policies pertaining to border security. Canada was chosen to be the starting point for new approach of cross-border security because of many factors. These include; common language, its size, wealth, significance, and technological knowledge based on computer literacy of the people living in Canada. Canada and United States also share some commonality concerning to law enforcement traditions. Implementing this new approach was met with a lot of ease as compared to when it would have been carried out it other country that has different characteristics.
Alper, D. K., &Loucky, J. (2007). Canada-US Border Securitization: Implications for Binational Cooperation. Canadian-American Public Policy, (72), 1.
Herzog, L. A. (2001). From Aztec to high tech: Architecture and landscape across the Mexico- United States border. JHU Press.